I hate Backing Track Bands – They are Killing Live Music!!!

Karaoke VersionBacking Tracks for live performance

This is how a musician friend of mine described bands that use backing tracks!

I used to agree with that but I’m changing my mind…..

It really is a contentious issue among some musicians!

Many logistical factors are at play here – money, venue, venue owners, musical experience, space, personnel and many more.

For many musicians it is less about the logistics and more about pride and dare I say it Ego (or lack of it)!

A lot of the debate online will focus on the “authenticity” of the musical experience.

Is a band  ” not really playing” if they use backing tracks?

Backing Tracks For Live Performance

“Glorified Karaoke”

For some musicians, there is no worse insult than be put in the same bracket as a Karaoke act…an insult too far!!!

As with all things in life, it’s not just as simple as that!

Let’s imagine this scenario that many of us have been in as solo or duo acts.

The bar owner is limited in space – they can’t fit a live band in there anyway!

Your musical integrity dictates that you play a well crafted and perfectly executed acoustic set – just two guitars, nothing else.

“Oh!!!” says the bar owner “we have a party in here on Saturday night and I wanted to keep it lively” He continues…

“sure you could put on a CD of the drums and stuff (that’s how he will describe your professionally created backing tracks!!!) and that will have them dancing”

So your ego yells ‘stuff his gig, I’m not that kind of artiste!”

However, the mortgage is due, new school uniforms are needed and Christmas is coming?

What do you do in that situation?

A young couple getting married have not much money left to pay for the biggest, bestest wedding band in the land with a full brass section and backing vocalists but want a lively set that will entertain their guests.

You are duo that can deliver that kind of experience (I know, I know  – nothing will come close to the full live band) using pro-sounding backing tracks.

Backing Tracks for Guitarists

You are a fine guitarists and vocalist act who get this wedding work because frankly you are cheaper than a full band?

  1. Is that something you should feel guilty about?
  2. Are you devaluing the live experience?
  3. Are you killing off musician’s job through the use of the backing tracks?
  4. Will someone in your audience look at you in dismay at the orchestral symphony coming from one guy and girl?

As with all good debates (and as musicians, we do like to argue!!!) there will strong arguments for and against.

If you are a brilliant singer who has fought tooth and nail with every drummer you have ever been in a band with and swore never to be in a band again!

What do you do retire and tell your gig war stories on a bar stool or use backing tracks to do what you have always loved doing?

Karaoke Version

For many musicians it’s a case of needs must!

They won’t let the criticism of other pious musicians put them off if they are making a living of something they love to do!

We would all love to play the big stages, have the full band and get paid the big wages but it defies economics for mots of us

One thing there is no doubt of!

The backing track has led to a proliferation of poor entertainment in some occasions!

A very average singer with a set of speakers, mic and an Iphone can be up and running and getting gigs pretty quickly.

Couple that with a venue you owner who does not really care and you soon have a race to the bottom as far as quality and renumeration for musicians.

However, I think we forget about the punter – yes some people will not care or notice how god a performance is as a long as a beat is going (especially after some beverages!)

For the discerning music fan, they will soon make their feelings known and vote with their feet – bars will not be so well attended the nights the bad acts or on!

Music fans should start to make their voices heard – “we want live bands”, “No More Tracks” or “That duo are superb”

A bar owner will take notice then!

That said how many times have you been in a venue with the full band who are no good, poorly mixed, completely unsuited to the crowd there.

A good sounding duo or solo act using backing tracks might have actually been a more appropriate musical fit in that circumstance!

It’s probably not as simple as “Backing Track” vs “Live”?

A quality musical experience for the audience is the goal – how that is achieved is less important depending on what your view is.

I love playing with live band but have also used backing tracks. Having a good PA system with good quality backing tracks supplemented the live playing.

It mean’t we could play songs, in places that never would have had a live band in the first place, by Pink Floyd to an audience that loved the guitar playing in a song  Comfortably Numb – scroll on down to watch the video

If you are using backing tracks, good quality is your guiding principle!

There are many free backing tracks that compiled using MIDI – essentially MIDI is just coded numbers enabling machines to talk to each other1

There is nothing inherently musical here and is dependent on the sound source and can be complicated to get right!

I have used a pro-sounding, customisable platform which really low cost for backing tracks but also s a unique band rehearsal tool ironically for full, live band pratice

Take a look at the video below to see it operation – you can take out instruments – vocals, guitar, bass and drums – depending on what your set up is – of Comfortably Numb

What bands use Backing Tracks?

Home / Karaoke Version / Turnkey solution
Turnkey Solution

Karaoke Version
Many acts supplement their live performance with pre-recorded tracks – is that any different?

Queen used a backing track in Bohemian Rhapsody – were they cheating? Did they use any recording trickery to record the song in the first place that has devalued in any way?

Backing Tracks recorded by real musicians has opened a new revenue stream for many. So not only are the backing tracks sounding brilliant for the performance but a musician has been paid to record them – surely that is a winner for musicians all around!

If you are using backing tracks – do you feel a sense of guilt? Do you find you have to defend yourself from other critical musicians?

More Guitar Stuff!!